Bourbon cream sandwich biscuits

Bourbon chocolate cream sandwich biscuits
Bourbon biscuits

I have a bit of a thing with cooking in that I love ‘reverse engineering’ recipes. That is, I love guessing the recipe and taking time to get it to as an exact replica as I can. It’s not just with baking but with all cooking, for instance trying to work out what’s gone into the paste to make a Thai curry I’ve enjoyed or the Grassmere-style gingerbread recipe that also features on my blog.

The recipe for Bourbons was one of the first I ever worked out as a ‘reverse-engineering’ exercise and rightly or wrongly I’m quite proud of how it’s turned out. I genuinely believe it is a near-as-dammit recipe to the shop-bought ones (although still keeping that extra-special homemade taste) and is totally from guess-work and trial and error to get it perfect. It has three types of sugar in: each brings a specific taste and does a specific job within the recipe. Icing sugar melts in with the butter and provides the bulk of the sweetness, soft brown sugar (or demerera) provides that more nutty flavour and because it’s crystals are larger takes longer to break down and combine in the cooking process from the heat, and finally the golden syrup is needed to help bind and without it the biscuits don’t taste like traditional Bourbons – you can definitely tell if it’s missing. Likewise with the ground ginger. Also, reciped that have cocoa only in the cream are definitely inferior! Go with the melted chocolate 🙂

If you do make it, please leave a message whether you think it stands up to the shop bought versions.


I do have a wavy biscuit cutter, which you can use if you have one, but I think the best results come if you have one of those wavy vegetable cutters (see pic below). You can make them straight if you do not have either.

There are several important things to making these biscuits ‘just so’. The main one is that they have to be uniform in size – take care to cut the same width and length of biscuit (I cut out a strip of card to measure against). Otherwise you’ll have quite the jigsaw trying to match up two biscuits that are the same each time you press two together with the cream.

This makes about 54 biscuits that are around 5cm x 2cm long, which means 27 sandwich biscuits. If you want less, I’d suggest freezing half the dough as it’s difficult to make anything with half an egg.

Another important point is that the holes aren’t just there to make them look Bourbon-y, they also stop the biscuits from rising too much (as the dough contains egg it will rise a little).

Finally, one last thing: do liberally use flour where you are cutting and rolling out – and the white flour won’t affect the final biscuit (ie you won’t get a white dusted biscuit rather than a chocolatey one).


  • Baking trays, lined with parchment or a silicon mat
  • Bowl
  • Wavy vegetable cutter or way-edge biscuit cutter
  • Palette knife
  • Small fork
wavy veggie cutter

Ingredients – for the biscuits

  • Unsalted butter, softened – 130g
  • Icing sugar – 60g
  • Soft brown sugar or demerera – 65g
  • Egg, medium – 1
  • Plain flour – 200g
  • Cocoa powder, sifted (as can be lumpy) – 45g
  • Golden syrup – 1 tablespoon,
  • Ground ginger – 1 teaspoon
  • Salt, fine table – large pinch

Ingredients – for the sandwich cream

  • Unsalted butter, very soft (but not melted) – 70g
  • Milk chocolate, melted – 30g
  • Icing sugar – 130g


  1. Mix all of the ingredients together for the biscuit dough – ensure they are thoroughly mixed
  2. Chill in the fridge until completely cool – about 20 mins
  3. Heat your oven to 160C fan or about 170C conventional (quite low for biscuits)
  4. Roll out the dough on a floured surface (I use a floured silicon mat) and make sure you dust the top of the dough or your rolling pin too
  5. I’d suggest rolling out the dough in several portions, if you are using a wavy cutter, as it’s difficult to cut across a wide piece of dough. If you are usig a proper biscuit cutter you can do it all in one go
  6. Roll out very thinly (the egg in the mixture will cause it to rise when cooking) – about 2mm
  7. Cut out the Bourbon shapes, transferring them as you go to the prepared baking sheet
  8. Prick each of the biscuits with the fork to create the tell-tale Bourbon pattern, or do a pattern of your own!
  9. Bake in the centre of the oven for 10 mins – they are done when tiny cracks start to appear (as they are chocolate biscuits you cannot judge if they are cooked by colouration)
  10. While they are cooking, prepare the filling
  11. Melt the chocolate and swirl in the butter and icing carefully so you don’t get clouds of icing sugar dust
  12. Once combined, you need to beat the cream very vigorously or use a hand mixer (I don’t think a stand mixer is necessary here nor is the amount enough to put in the bottom of a mixer – they don’t handle small amounts particularly well)
  13. Once the biscuits are done leave them until they are quite cold before assembling
  14. To assemble, pick up one biscuit and find a matching partner
  15. Spread a small amount of the cream (don’t be too generous as it’ll be too much) on the reverse of one biscuit and sandwich the other on top (so that the two sides with holes in are both on the outside)
  16. Leave for about 30 minutes for the cream to harden then keep in an airtight biscuit tin

Published by Ink Sugar Spice

I’m Lynn and I’m a baker, pasta maker, patissiere, cook, crafter, designer, artist and illustrator. There's little that I can't make by hand. I have been making bread and pasta, baking and creating recipes for 30 years since a teenager. I was featured as the 'pasta fanatic' in episode three of Nadiya's Family Favourites on BBC2 (July 2018) I work as a web and graphic designer/copywriter/social media manager and have an honours degree in theatre design and have many artican crafts, carpentry and design skills. 💙 #pasta #food #baking #bread #patisserie #confectionery #art #crafts #recipes #blogger #design #illustration

Please do leave a reply or raise a question here 💙

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: